Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong

Diocesan Synod

Group Three – Social Concern

Second Draft

PROLOGUE

Soon after Hong Kong experienced the historical changeover of sovereignty in 1997, the Asian financial crisis broke out and Hong Kong underwent an economic recession. Though the economy is recovering, the gap between wealthy and poor is getting worse. Many people are suffering from a freeze or cut in wage, lay off and unemployment. The living standard of many people has generally deteriorated. In the face of these adverse economic changes, certain groups of people are being treated as scapegoats. They are usually the powerless, such as the new arrivals, migrant workers, recipients of welfare, low-income labour and so on. They are being neglected, discriminated against and exploited. In view of this, not only has the Government refused to take care of their needs seriously and try to soften the atmosphere of resistance and intolerance, but it has further cut the welfare expenses and seems to reinforce discrimination through its policies.

In face of the unjust social structure and the general culture of lack of concern and acceptance towards the underprivileged, the Church, as the sign of the Kingdom of God on earth, and also the conscience of society and yeast to generate charity and justice, has the responsibility to bear witness of loving others through proclamation and action. She has the mission of showing preferential option to the poor and upholding human dignity. The Church should stand up for the poor and provide services and pastoral care, to empower the weak and the poor and assist them to integrate into society. Moreover, the Church should arouse social awareness of the faithful through various kinds of formation. Furthermore, to pinpoint the root of social problems, the Church also has to transform unjust policy and structure through advocacy.

Based on these principles, the Social Concern group has chosen to investigate the problems of the deprived and the poor, especially the marginalised and special needs groups, migrant workers, new arrivals and grassroots labour. Meanwhile, the group also shows concern for the care of the environment and other life concerns. Nowadays, many people use natural resources carelessly, to the detriment of the environment and community. Due to the ageing population, more health care service should be provided to the elderly through community support. Due to the change of sovereignty in 1997, with the subsequent decline in democratic system, the Church should fulfil its civic responsibility by participating in the promotion and monitoring of the democratic system.

During the first call of the Diocesan Synod, the term ‘Servant and Prophetic Roles’ was added to the Social Concern group. However, most members considered that these two roles cannot be separated. After six months of discussion and reflection, as well as considering the comments from the first consultation, it is unanimously resolved to delete the term ‘Servant and Prophetic Roles’. Our group thinks that ‘Servant, Prophet’ is not the same as social concern. Every Christian has the roles of prophetic, servant and priest; it is not appropriate to take out two of them for the social concern.

Despite the fact that the Church persistently reveals Christian values in every aspect, there is still negligence and mistakes. Inspired by the public apology of Pope John Paul II, the Social Concern group also calls for the Diocese in Hong Kong to give a public apology for all the negligence and mistakes, to show the humbleness of the Church and the willingness to be reconciled and cooperate with the society.

In the past, the Diocesan Curia, church organisations and individual believers tried to express their social concern in different ways. However, the social consciousness of the Church on the whole is not conspicuous, and the understanding of believers towards the social mission of the Church is not comprehensive enough. Thus, there is a need to set a long-term plan and to co-ordinate various church institutions, in order to actualise the social mission of the Church systematically and strategically.

  1. REFLECTION ON CONCRETE SITUATION
  2. 1.1 Reflection on Faith

    In reflecting on the three years of public life of Jesus, we draw from his teachings and revelation that he is often among the poor, the sick, and the marginalised1. Therefore, we as his followers, should walk in the footsteps of his mission to be present with those who suffer, serve, heal, and save, and to continue his redemptive works to establish his earthly kingdom.

    The Social Concern group, in expressing its concern to carry out the Christian mission, reflected on the misery, distress and sufferings of those who have less, the powerless, those being socially discriminated against. It expresses the desire to improve the life situation of these people and aspire to a society which is more humane and more just. Reflection on the early Church writings increases our understanding of the gaps between the rich and the poor. In the social teachings of the Church, we are invited to examine the signs of the times, the dignity and rights of workers, the relations of workers' union and employers, and the workers' solidarity and societal order.

    In the pursuit of freedom and truth, the Church is the defender of the human person and promotes the advancement of individuals through education and formation of true ideals as well as the creation of democratic structures of participation and shared responsibility.

    In reflecting on our redemptive mission "I came that they may have life, and have it abundantly", we see that this life involves all aspects and stages of human life in order to achieve full significance till eternity. Therefore, every threat to human dignity and life must necessarily be felt in the Church's very heart. The Church adopts a role in the defence of life issues and protector of the environment by restoring a sense of reverence for the whole of creation. Sin makes people accomplices of one another and causes concupiscence, violence, and injustice to reign among us. Sin gives rise to social situations and institutions that are contrary to divine goodness. Structural sin or social sin leads victims to do evil.

    It is our moral duty to care for the environment, not only for our own good but also for the good of future generations. It is worth remembering that in calling on Christians to work and sacrifice themselves in the service of human development the Synod Fathers were drawing upon some of the core insights of biblical and ecclesial tradition.

    1.2 Present Situation

      1. The Deprived

    1. Poverty
    2. The gap between the wealthy and the poor is getting greater. In 1999, the medium income was approximately $9,000. The number of the lowest income families earning $3,000 per month was 200,000, while another 200,000 belonged to the higher income group of $70,000. The gap between these two groups is 23 times, while in 1996, it was only 13 times. Between 1997 and 1999, those earning $3,000 per month reached 100,000, an increase of 75%, while the group with $30,000 income increased by 15%, totalling 300,000. In the last decade, the low-income workers total 67 % of the workforce, increasing from 210,000 to 360,000.

      There is some disagreement on the issue of setting a poverty line. Some LegCo and District Board members proposed to set a poverty line (e.g. the poverty line = CSSA amount) so that those belonging to this group could be identified to receive assistance. Measures like CSSA or retraining can then be taken to help them. However, the Government did not accept this possibility with the rationale that the present social security system can already adapt to various needs at various levels.

      In Hong Kong, the Church has not openly taken a stand on the poverty issue / line, but in the reflection of St. Chrysostom and St. Ambrose, there is a clear demand that the community's resources invite us to have the common stewardship to be shared among the rich and the poor.

      Who are the poor?

      From various surveys, "the poor" are regarded as those who have no specific skill, no stable job and income, no pension, low education and poor health. The poor desire equal opportunity, no stigmatisation or discrimination because of age, sex, occupation or family status.

      There are around 900,000 people in poverty. This includes:

      those on social assistance scheme, (130,000 elderly and 120,000 handicapped);

      single parent women with young children (30,000);

      the new arrival families (about 300,000); and the working poor (300,000) - those who earn below $3,000 per month.

    3. Disadvantaged and Special Needs Groups
    4. Disadvantaged refers to the disabled, street sleepers, drug addicts, discharged prisoners, sex workers, elderly living alone, mentally ill and mentally handicapped. They lack the opportunity and assistance to participate and integrate into society. Thus, they have difficulties in looking for jobs, and are discriminated against, or treated as a group in need of sympathy.

    5. Migrant Workers
    6. Migrant workers in Hong Kong face many kinds of problems and difficulties such as: contract violations, forced labour, loss of human dignity, underpayment, lack of privacy and human treatment, family related problems, lack of faith formation. In this land of fortune, many of them find themselves less fortunate for they are friendless, culturally estranged, linguistically disadvantaged and economically vulnerable.

    7. New Arrivals

As the Hong Kong political, economic and social systems are completely different from that on the Mainland, the newly arrived people will encounter difficulties during the process of integration. This includes: housing, employment, family life and marriage. They are often discriminated against. In education, since the English standard of most new arrivals is generally low, they are often laughed at by their peers.

      1. Social

    1. Labour
    2. Under the situation of economic recession, everything must be cost-effective, therefore, in the workplace the team atmosphere, friendliness, spirit of mutual support have all vanished. Those unemployed or having difficulty finding jobs are being discriminated against, which results in a loss of dignity, and suffering of high stress. Consequently, the difference between rich and poor is getting wider.

    3. Caring for the Environment
    4. Hong Kong has been seriously polluted in recent decades, but the public generally lacks the awareness of caring for the environment. Both the Government and business sectors do not want to spend money and resources on improving the environment. Equitable distribution of environmental resources deserves attention, e.g. air-cleaning efforts seem to focus on Central and Causeway Bay. The right to information must be safeguarded as the government is the main source of environmental information while business sectors rarely disclose related information, such as genetically engineered food labelling.

    5. Life Concerns
    6. Due to the ageing population, the proportion of elderly persons in need of health care services is increasing, which leads to an increase in the resources needed. Health care is changing from hospitals to community support. Those who have recovered from mental illnesses usually have to face discrimination and non-acceptance by society etc. HIV/AIDS is not just a health issue. It influences a whole range of social, legal, economic, gender, cultural and ethical issues. It is above all a human condition and therefore of concern to the Church and a subject for theological reflection and pastoral and justice-oriented action. It is hoped that a more widespread compassionate and non-judgmental Church response to those living with HIV/AIDS can be achieved. During last year, Diocesan Pastoral Care Services has served a total of about 25,600 beds in public hospitals and more than 65,000 patients/relatives/hospital staff through dedicated efforts of pastoral care workers and volunteers. Hospital Pastoral Care Units have also co-operated with Parishes to provide support for patients.

    7. Civic participation (Christians’ Participation)

In Hong Kong, the opportunities for civic participation remain limited, despite important improvements in the political system over the past decades. The chief shortcoming lies in the partial democratic reforms, whereby political power is still in the hands of the business elite. The overall level of political participation of Hong Kong Chinese is very low. Since the mid-‘80s however, political activism has increased and voting has become the most important mode of participation. Social participation, which is closely related to political participation, is also at an unsatisfactory level.

2. BASIC PRINCIPLES

In our reflection, we examined our present situation to look for the signs of the times. We adopted some tools and a set of principles to measure broadly which things we thought had fallen above or below the benchmark. References were made to the basic principles of the World's Summit on Poverty (1995), Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Universal Declaration of Handicapped Persons (1975), Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women (1979), Charter on Children Rights (1989) and Charter on Youth (1993). Referring to requirements and recommendations from the World Health Organisation (WHO) on general well-being and health environment, and International Labour Organisation (ILO) on labour law to protect workers’ rights and unions, our group endeavoured to identify what we have achieved and what are the shortfalls, as outlined in the following chapter.

2.1 Vision and Mission

2.1.1 Disadvantaged and Special Needs Groups

The Church provides various services to the disadvantaged and special needs groups in order to encourage them to participate in the church’s activities and integrate into the community, e.g. through the services of the Diocesan Commission for Pastoral Services to the Disabled and the parish services to the prisoners, discharged prisoners and street sleepers.

2.1.2 Migrant Workers

In response to the growing migrant phenomenon, the Diocese of Hong Kong has implemented procedures to respond to this problem: established the Diocesan Pastoral Centre for Filipinos, opened three shelter houses for the terminated domestic helpers; established the Commission for the Pastoral Care of (Filipino) Migrants; and invited the CBCP – ECMI (Catholic Bishops Conference of the Philippines – Episcopal Commission on Migrant and Itinerant Peoples) to send two Filipino priests to minister to the migrants, the Diocese issued guidelines and openings for the migrant workers as well as providing pastoral care service.

 

 

2.1.3 New Arrivals

The Diocesan Working Groups to co-ordinate the services offered to the new arrivals and set a ‘New Arrivals Day’. Caritas and Parishes have organised induction and extension programmes. Caritas has also set up hotlines and counselling service. The new arrivals are also mobilised to participate in volunteer services. Due to limited resources, there is still room for improvement in these services.

2.1.4 Labour

The Diocese has set up the Hong Kong Catholic Commission for Labour Affairs which provides laity formation and two centres for workers.

In the past, the Commission has supported workers who claimed on Job Security & Labour Law protection concerning safe working conditions, just income and decrease in salaries, to fix a basic salary respecting the dignity of workers, redundancy and dismissal situations, rest days and May Day as public holiday, maternity leave and equal occupational opportunity, Labour Department opening hours at a time fitting workers’ lunch time as well as reaction to the weaknesses and loopholes in the Mandatory Provident Fund.

The Commission has also given comments about restructuring of work and the need for a healthy local industrial policy, the need to reduce working hours and to create employment opportunities, respect for the workers through having time for social participation, against unilateral changes concerning work contracts and respect the right of workers to their social life.

2.1.5 Caring for the Environment

In October 1998, Cardinal John Baptist Wu Cheng-chung issued a pastoral letter on environment, urging the faithful to be concerned about pollution and ecology. The Diocese has urged a communion between heaven and humankind, including care for nature. Individuals, parish groups and Church schools have joined in organic gardening or green awareness programs. All in all, however, the diocese does not actively promote care for the environment. Few Church groups have spoken out on environment issues.

2.1.6 Life Concerns

As the demand for health care services is increasing, it requires more co-ordination and training from the organisations in the community and the Church. We should revise the role of Catholic priest & pastoral workers, review the objectives of the Diocese in establishing Catholic Hospitals as well as provide more support.

2.1.7 Civic Participation (Christian’s participation)

The seven church organisations have been actively involved in social affairs and expressed opinions on concrete social problems and social policies. They have also organised social conscientization program and promoted the Church’s social teachings in the Church. These organisations also express opinions on policies related to social welfare vis-a-vis her clients as well as organise formation programs and activities which show concern for social justice issues.

 

 

  1. CONCRETE RECOMMENDATIONS

3.1 Poverty

      1. Short Term:

    1. The new MPF system has been implemented so that there will be a Provident Fund for all retired workers. Catholics employers are urged never to avoid giving workers its PF contribution by offering a contract of less than 60 days.
    2. Parish - Establish a confidential list of the poor in the neighbourhood, and match services for their needs.
    3. Diocese - create job opportunity schemes for the poor, so that they are exposed to work experience and do not need to rely on CSSA long term. (Suggest Caritas to form co-operatives to alleviate their dependency from the burden of high cost of living, such as flower, food, hair cutting, supply casual domestic workers after training)

      1. Medium / Long Term

    1. Individuals - welcome poor families as friends and give support, expose oneself to poor people in solidarity with Christ. This can be carried out through our neighbourhoods or at parish level.
    2. Diocese to set up a watchdog group to follow in depth the poverty issue, to reduce poverty, produce materials to conscientize Church members, and hopefully to speak out on the issue through collective action.
    3. The Diocese to set up skills training to eradicate economic poverty.
    4. Caritas and Religious Orders - to upgrade their education and teach them a means of livelihood.
    5. Parish feast should be kept simple and money given to the poor in response to simplicity of life.
    6. Introduce a "family wage" in Catholic Institutions. Catholic employers to be encouraged to share their wealth with low income employees by provision of staff medical benefits, or housing scheme/allowance, or children education allowance, or widow allowance.

    1. Disadvantaged and Special Needs Groups
      1. Formation
      2. That formation of the clergy, Sisters and catechists include an introduction to and exposure to the situation and needs of the disadvantaged and those with special needs in society, e.g. care for the deprived, sign language training for the deaf, etc. in order to evangelise and assist their spiritual life.

      3. Parish – Support

    1. That parishes set up a network and list to understand and respond to those in need in their area (e.g. people with disabilities, street sleepers, sex workers and the elderly living alone) – their backgrounds and needs in order to offer service and resources when required.
    2. Parishes to encourage and accept the deprived as parish members, so that they can participate and serve the church. The church should bring an important message to the disadvantaged, i.e. that they have to take initiative to fight for their own rights.
    3. Parishes initiate the forming of small faith communities to encourage and facilitate the development of self-confidence and acceptance of people with mental disabilities. This will facilitate their being welcomed and becoming part of the parish as a whole.
    4. That parishes take the initiative to understand and debate unfair and discriminatory policies, voice their opinion to the government and work towards changing public attitudes.

      1. People with disabilities

    1. Improve the access and related facilities in Church, Service Building, Retreat House, Pastoral Centres and all church organisations. Post sign language interpreter during liturgy.
    2. Reserve seats for the disabled so that it is easier for them to adapt and be looked after.
    3. If the parish has financial or architectural problems and cannot improve the access, then parish can initiate the formation of special task group for the concern of the disabled, to mobilise volunteers to assist the disabled to participate in church’s activities.
    4. Support and encourage the disabled to actively participate in the Church’s life.
    5. Reserve seats for the disabled during important church events e.g. mission Sunday, evangelisation events, etc.

      1. Mentally Handicapped

    1. Create opportunities for the members of the church to get in touch with mentally handicapped children and adults, especially those who are baptised. Caritas and other Catholic organisations that have suitable training centres and related services can provide resources for their gathering.
    2. Establish at least one mentally handicapped group at each deanery with, if possible, a spiritual leader who is a priest, brother or sister.
    3. These groups could meet at least once or twice every month, so that they can communicate with each other and have sharing, in order to build a relationship with the mentally handicapped.
    4. Mobilise and train volunteers who are concerned for the mentally handicapped to be the convenor (need special training) and leader.

      1. Sex Workers
      2. There are very few revision classes for the primary school children in the evening. As sex workers work during night, they cannot help teach their children, it is proposed that church and Catholic organisations provide revision classes to assist these single parent families.

      3. Single Elderly
      4. Hong Kong has an ageing population. Some of the elderly Catholic cannot be admitted to the homes organised by Catholic organisation and have entered those operated by other religions, which lead to their losing their belief in Christ and converting to other religions. The Church should keep in close contact with these elderly, pay them regular visits and provide pastoral services.

      5. Families with difficulties

Families with difficulties, e.g. physically handicapped should be the top priority when planning events in the parish. The parish can form visiting groups to pay regular visits.

 

 

    1. Migrant Workers
      1. At the Diocesan Level

    1. To advocate for the ratification and implementation of the UN Convention on protection of the rights of all migrants and members of their families.
    2. More active participation of the Church in Hong Kong in drafting of policies relating to all migrants regardless of their religious beliefs or nationalities through the Justice and Peace Commission and the Commission on the Filipino Migrants.
    3. Involvement in Government sponsored programs/projects related to migrants such as AIDS prevention, environmental campaigns, protection of women, racial discrimination in work etc.
    4. To network with national, regional and international forum/groups especially the Asian Migrant Desk.
    5. To institute a Migrant Sunday according to the instruction on the Pastoral Care of People who Migrate from the Pontifical Council for the Pastoral Care of Migrants and Itinerant People.
    6. Diocesan Centre for Filipinos should be changed into Diocesan Centre for Migrant Workers.
    7. The Diocese of Hong Kong should encourage its people who hire domestic helpers to pay the basic wage and to give them a day off.

      1. At the Parish Level

    1. To conscientizise the local Christian communities (priests, religious, parishioners, schools) to respond to the dehumanisation of migrant workers. Parishes should provide not only liturgical services, physical structures and programs but also opportunities for integrating and growth as a truly Christian community. Parishes should also be aware of their social needs, providing appropriate programs, formation and co-ordination, and initiate activities that will improve communication and mutual understanding between the migrant workers and local people.
    2. To establish a Parish Migrant Desk in parishes overflowing with migrants, to attend to migrant social concern and work related problems (para-legal assistance, and advocacy desk in co-ordination with Diocesan Centre for Migrant Workers)
    3. To make church and school premises available to migrants for social, personal and spiritual development.
    4. To encourage the local parishes to include the migrant workers in their Parish Council.

    1. New Arrivals
      1. Change in Attitude
      2. Each parish to respond to the World Migrants' Day (in HK, the Diocese has selected the last Sunday of the Year before Advent). This day is set aside for Christians to grow in an attitude of understanding and dialogue; to improve human relationship, reduce inter-cultural gaps and discrimination, increase sensitivity to the needs of others and appreciation of multiplicity of cultures; Christian groups, homes or institutions are to express action in the form of openness of hearts and minds, by sharing hospitality with migrants or foreigners in our enriched society.

         

      3. Pledge Support

    1. The church to join force to show our hospitality and support to the new arrivals. Each parish or association is invited to pledge to support financially a number of new arrivals families, the amount being decided by the New Arrivals Pastoral Commission.
    2. This support aims to reduce poverty among the newly arrived and prevent social threats to our future society, and to bring about greater integration. The diocese to set up or entrust the co-ordination of this work to the Diocesan Working Group of New Arrivals.

      1. Set Up Mutual Help Groups
      2. Parish social concern group and other parish groups to set up social support groups, parents' group, women's group, men's group and children's groups. These groups will meet occasionally for mutual support, self-help, to alleviate stress in urban living, to learn to cope with parental responsibilities and daily living, and to enhance their understanding and love of family life, and human relationship, to bring about peace and unity in an integrated society.

      3. Set Up Network System
      4. Parish to set up a social network system to render support to those living alone, at risk or in special need, to learn self-help, self-confidence, fulfilment and empowerment, or to make services available to them.

      5. To advocate for policy change

Parish to advocate for policy change so as to alleviate poverty and change the marginal criteria of social security net.

    1. Labour
      1. Formation of workers and employers organisation

    1. Workers unite together to form a union to improve their own situation.
    2. With an unbiased and objective attitude, parish and deanery are encouraged to organise groups for workers and employers, so that they can have sharing in order to improve relationships. These groups should also organise catechism courses and social teachings of the church.
    3. Through sharing, both the employers and workers can understand the problems faced today, so that they may be in a better position to understand the workers’ dignity and rights, the value of their work and their mission.

      1. Support

Most workers’ organisations are formed in the community and some are in line with political parties. To enhance the prophetic role in society, the Church should fight for the room to speak and develop formation, e.g.:

    1. Pay more attention and analyse the changes in the work situation, provide faith reflection and speak out for these groups through letters to the media and the public.
    2. Through letters to the media and the public, share common views with employers and workers’ organisations. To fulfil this role, organise social research centres to gather those who believe in the ‘option for the poor’ and to conduct a comprehensive survey on labour-related policy, present living and working conditions of the workforce, and comment through the media.
    3. Workers and employers’ organisations urge the Government to evaluate the policy of industry and employment, including revision of vocational training, propose changes to labour or social protection laws in order to protect the long term benefits of the employers and workers - on the basis that every one has the opportunity to work.
    4. Convey the message of enhancing workers’ rights through conducting various formation programmes, forum, publish magazines and other multi-media.
    5. To show support, the Church should appoint suitable full time or part time priests to assist the workers’ organisations.

      1. Recommendations

    1. Workers’ rights and the social teaching of the Church should be included in catechumenate classes.
    2. During the year, experts should preach regular sermons in churches, following a schedule based on the contents of the Social Encyclicals and the Church in the Modern World.
    3. All priests and religious should take the initiative to contact workers and understand the problems faced today, so that they may be in a better position to encourage them to understand their dignity, the value of their work and their mission as workers.
    4. Caritas to open centres for mutual support of workers’ families: e.g. childcare, mutual life/training, women, consultation.
    5. Monitor the legislation and implementation closely to forbid the employment of illegal part-time migrant workers, which is unjust and directly affecting the local workers. A group of qualified and concerned people should determine and publicise a standard family living wage for Hong Kong. Employers/employees could take this as a guide for their own wage policies.
    6. The Diocese of Hong Kong should organise as soon as possible a Social Justice Year/month. During the year, experts should preach regular sermons in churches, following a schedule based on the contents of the Social Encyclicals and the Church in the Modern World.

    1. Caring for the Environment
      1. Internal

    1. Christians have to respect and restore the integrity of the earth’s ecological systems, and to learn the biological diversity of creatures and ecology. Encourage education of environmental ethics and the concept that abuse of creation is a sin - to be included in Sunday schools, catechism and religious education curriculum.
    2. Ecological spirituality: clerics and spiritual guides remind the Catholics to respect the earth and creation through homilies and retreats. Liturgy can also include the praise of nature, through traditional Chinese celebrations like the beauty of the moon at mid-Autumn Festival. The diocesan audio-visual centre to produce programmes to raise consciousness of the environment.
    3. Parishes are encouraged to hold a Sunday liturgy on environment on or around June 5 – the World Environment Day. Special Liturgy, tree plantings and gardening are suggested.
    4. Simple life: Christians should lead a simple life. The Church is advised to organise more vegetarian spiritual programmes, and to avoid wasting food and resources. Parish celebrations to be kept simple.

 

 

 

      1. External

    1. Church schools and organisations should urge meal providers not to use Styrofoam and non-recyclable utensils, and to provide healthy food. Diocese may adopt a policy of using recycled paper for all departments. It is encouraged to run an organic garden for parishioners to experience green life.
    2. The Church ought to have a spokesperson to give opinions on environmental matters.
    3. Monitoring Politicians: Catholics should consider candidates’ platform and attitude on environment issues, and urge District Board members and Legislators to promote and monitor the environmental situations in the district.
    4. Demand that the Government implement a policy of recycling materials such as paper and bottles.
    5. Labelling waste. Urge the government and business sector to release related information concerning the pollution emitted from factories in China, which were relocated from Hong Kong during the 1980s. Defend people’s environmental right and monitor the equal distribution of resources in improving the environment, especially in low-income areas.
    6. Church organisations should call for peace and an end to violence, so as to prevent wars that will destroy nature.

    1. Life Concerns
      1. Long Term

    1. A statutory body of the Diocese comprised of lay representatives of various Catholic medical and healthcare professional organisations should be formed. Appointed members of the body could have direct and timely discussion/communication with official clergyman of the diocese and should be delegated to make timely and appropriate responses on healthcare issues, especially medical/ethical issues.
    2. The Diocese should respond to specific issues, for instance, healthcare financing issues. Since the Diocese has influence on Government policies, these will have an impact on the Hospital Authority hospitals.
    3. The Diocese should make official statements on issues like euthanasia, abortion. There should be an official spokesperson from the Diocese on healthcare issues.
    4. Education relating to medical ethics on life/death issues should be promoted. An Ethical Committee can be set up to establish policies/guidelines for healthcare workers to handle difficult situations, making front-line staff more accountable for their actions.
    5. We should revive the role of Catholic priest and pastoral workers, review the objectives of the Diocese in establishing Catholic Hospitals and enhance religious atmosphere in Catholic Hospitals.
    6. Setting up of Hong Kong Catholic Hospitals Association should be considered. The Diocese should give more support to Catholic Hospitals and recognise their united force.
    7. In Catholic Hospitals, there should be briefing/orientation sessions on topics like abortion, euthanasia to train the carers. More time & resources should be designated for education in attitudes, values and philosophy. Catholic Staff Association can be set up at individual hospitals to re-cultivate Catholic spirit and enhance linkage amongst Catholic staff.
    8. More support from laypersons to take up some duties of the priests to release them for religious activities should be considered.
    9. All of the above to be implemented by the Diocese through setting up a mechanism in the long term.

      1. Increasing demand from elderly patients requiring health care services

    1. As healthcare services provided by the Government for elderly are not sufficient, the Diocese could set up a special task force to investigate the issue and make/implement recommendations, e.g. to consider setting up of elderly homes/services.
    2. As the number of elderly homes are increasing, each Parish can increase visits to elderly homes and provide support/care to needy singleton and sick elderly in the vicinity.
    3. To nurture, from childhood, among Catholics in Parishes attitudes of care and concern for elderly
    4. To be implemented by the Diocese/Social Concern Groups of Parishes in the long term, with support from Caritas.

      1. Hospice

    1. To consider setting up Hospice Care Units at Catholic Private Hospitals.
    2. To be implemented by the Diocese.

      1. Community Care

    1. The Diocese/Parishes can cooperate with Caritas or other organisations to provide healthy check-up services. However, the promotion of healthy life-styles is more important. Assistance from the Catholic Doctors/Nurses Guild could also be solicited.
    2. The Diocese/Parishes can help in the promotion of awareness among Catholics and the general public about patients' rights and responsibilities as stipulated in the Patients' Charter so as to enhance their sense of partnership in their own health.
    3. Parishes can actively promote and encourage care & concern for needy patients, especially chronic patients.
    4. To be implemented by the Diocese/Parishes, in association with the Catholic Doctors/Nurses Guild & other organisations in the long term.

      1. Mental Health

    1. Since there are quite a number of needy in various Parishes, the Diocese/Parishes should organise teams to actively provide service. Assistance from the indirect approach of Religion, instead of from professionals, will be more easily acceptable for those with mental problems. Parishes can help those who have recovered from mental illnesses to build up confidence/spirit based on Gospel values and integrate into the community.
    2. To be implemented by a special team within Social Concern Groups, with special assistance from Caritas, in the long term.

      1. Commercial Ethics

    1. Parishes can promote education/awareness among Catholics about food health. The Diocese can also influence the Government for better monitoring measures.
    2. To be implemented by Parishes/Diocese in the long term.

      1. The Marginalized (AIDS)

    1. Thorough research of local services to refer HIV/AIDS affected persons for volunteer chore assistance, case management Counselling, support groups, housing and food assistance.
    2. Recruitment of volunteers from the parishes for AIDS service agencies. Education for all parish constituencies about the experience of AIDS that people have, issues around preventing transmission of the virus and importance of acceptance for HIV/AIDS affected persons to avoid unnecessary discrimination. Sex education should be started as from primary education.
    3. The mission and role of Catholic private hospitals should be reviewed in relation to services for the marginalized, e.g. HIV/AIDS affected persons should be accepted by Catholic hospitals for services.
    4. To be implemented by the Diocese/Parishes in the long term.

      1. Pastoral Care

    1. The approach of the Diocesan Pastoral Care Services in servicing all hospitals needs further thinking. Credibility of pastoral care services may be built up through focusing on a few hospitals.
    2. Resources and manpower allocated to pastoral care services should be increased; development of volunteers’ services should be enhanced.
    3. The Diocese is to raise the standard, upgrade professional status and personal emoluments of pastoral care workers so that they can be well accepted by other healthcare professionals to join the team for holistic care.
    4. A Sunday can be designated as "Pastoral Care Day" and promotion at Parishes can publicise the work of Diocesan pastoral care services amongst Catholics and the general public.

    1. To be implemented by the Diocese/Parishes in the long term.

    1. Civic Participation (Christian’s participation)
      1. Internal

Short Term

    1. Transparency, openness and participation should characterise all levels of the Church, including diocesan, parish, school, community centres and so on.
    2. Parish Council. The parish should aim at full participation in the election of the parish council. In the everyday running of the Council the parish should aim at co-responsibility and collective leadership, so as to build a participatory Church. The parish finance committee should make detailed and regular reports to the parish council and publicise these reports to the parishioners through the newsletter or notice board.
    3. The Church should at all levels explain its prophetic role and social mission, that is, to proclaim what is right and to condemn evil and injustice.
    4. Effective formation on social concern should not merely be academic, but should also be accompanied by a guided exposure to the realities of our city. Children Sunday school, catechetical class, continuing formation for laity, small faith communities, courses of seminary college should integrate social concern activities into the program.
    5. The related church institutions should provide support to the parish social concern groups.

Long Term

    1. Retreats and days of recollection for politicians and officials who are Christians could be promoted. This is to deepen their religious faith and strengthen their commitment to the common good of our city.
    2. To encourage the Church institutions, including diocesan commissions, offices and Caritas to strengthen co-operation and co-ordination in the areas of social formation and advocacy.
    3. Parish social concern groups should strengthen their co-operation and co-ordination. Together with diocesan social concern institutions, they are encouraged to hold regular meetings to exchange experiences, discuss joint projects and discuss strategies to respond to concrete social issues.

      1. External

Long Term

    1. On the Diocesan level, the Church leaders should speak up on social justice or influential social events when appropriate, acting as a social conscience and moral force, which can provide guidance to the laity.
    2. The Church organisations should further strengthen the co-operation with other religious and non-religious groups.
    3. Love and concern to the Motherland should be promoted through organising exposure trip to Mainland China, seminars and sharing meetings, research on specific topics. Through direct contact with people and social analysis and discussion, a deeper understanding of Mainland China, Taiwan and the cross-strait relationship are fostered.
    4. To encourage Catholics to inculcate in Christian values when participating in, making decisions and commenting on political affairs.

Short Term

    1. To encourage Catholics and Church organisations to express opinions related to justice according to the Church's social teachings and employ different strategies to affect public opinions and social policies.
    2. To encourage co-operation among schools, parish youth groups and diocesan social concern institutions. For example, value education, especially core values which are being cherished by the Church, and civic education have to be strengthen in school religious and ethic lessons and youth formation.
    3. Since the Church values the democratic system, the Church or this Diocesan Synod should take appropriate measures publicly to express the wish of electing the Chief Executive and all members of the Legislative Council by universal suffrage because the people of Hong Kong are now sufficiently mature for such a development.

CONCLUSION

To conclude then, it is true to say that in the past, the Diocesan Curia, Church organisations and individual believers tried to express their social concern in different ways. However, social consciousness of the Church on the whole was not conspicuous and the understanding of believers towards the social mission of the Church was not comprehensive enough. The whole area of structural change needs to be addressed. This can only come about through attitudinal change, a change of heart evoked through sensitivity and exposure to the needs of the poor. To achieve this, there is a need for conscience formation on all levels in the Church. In practical terms this calls for a long-term plan and the co-ordinating of various Church institutions, so as to actualise the social mission of the Church systemically and strategically.

Appendices

PROLOGUE

Prophetic role of the Diocese

We have to admit that on the whole the entire Diocese’s concern for and influence on social policies was still weak, so that its prophetic role was not yet conspicuous. In order to help us in the future to assume both the prophetic and servant roles in a balanced way, we must make the prophetic role of the entire Diocese more conspicuous, with special attention to justice, human rights, labour, medical services, and the contributions of women and families to society. Accordingly, we shall also put more effort into such areas as investment in human resources, the training of qualified personnel, and the promotion of awareness on the part of the faithful so that all the people of God can play a prophetic role in their own spheres. (March into the Bright Decade: Pastoral Interim Report and Proposals, 1995, 6.3)

1. REFLECTION

1.1 Concern on Poverty

  1. "In so far as you did this to one of the least of these brothers of mine, you did it to me." (Matt. 25:40)
  2. "Are we a Church of the poor, for the poor?" (Ecclesia in Asia 1999, No. 34)
  3. "Actions on behalf of justice and participation in the transformation of the world fully appear .…as a constitutive dimension of the preaching of the gospel …. of the church mission of redemption of the human race and its liberation from every oppressive situation." (Justice in the World 1971, P.8)
  4. "When we attend to the needs of those in want, we give them what is theirs, not ours. More than performing works of mercy, we are paying a debt of justice." (St. John Chrysostom, New Catechisis, No. 2402)
  5. "You are not making a gift of your possessions to the poor person. You are handing over to him what is his. For what has been given in common for the use of all, you have arrogated to yourself. The world is given to all, and not only to the rich." (Saint Ambrose, Populorum Progressio, No. 23)

1.2 The Marginalised

  1. "Love one another as I have loved you." (John 13:34)
  2. "In seeking to promote human dignity, the Church shows a preferential love for the poor and the voiceless, because the Lord had identified himself with them in a special way." (Ecclesia, No. 34)
  3. Hong Kong society has the same experience as the Early Church where certain groups were overlooked (Acts 6:1). Jesus welcomed teachers and the scribes but he came on earth primarily for the sick and sinners who are often situated on the margins of our society. These people who are found on the margins need to be placed in the centre. They need to be integrated into our communities in order to lessen their sense of loneliness.
  4. Jesus suffered the degradation of the lowest in order to raise them up again. The Church's contact with these people is often considered to be "charity" but charity in this sense does not necessarily mean the love of God. In order to exercise our prophetic and servant roles, a new mentality and spiritually and formation process are needed, whereby charity does not necessarily mean "doing" but will mean "living with, being with". Jesus does everything together with us. This process must begin with the heart and place the emphasis not on doing but more on meeting with and experience with the elderly, people with disabilities, street sleepers, sex workers, etc.
  5. Since we experience Christ in the Blessed Sacrament and in the poor, we need to develop a spirituality in which there is respect for what each one can be and what each one can do. As Church we need to look at the whole cycle of life and develop an outlook which will be inclusive and encourage solidarity among all.

1.3 The Migrant Workers

  1. In the Old Testament God revealed his salvation plan through the history of a people, the Israelites. They experienced a nomadic life, the exile, and the promise of land. They experienced the loss of humanity - pains and the fulfilment of God's salvation plan - gains. Thus they were instructed: "Do not mistreat migrants or oppress them, for you were migrants in Egypt. " (Exod.22.20)
  2. In the New Testament we see that Jesus experienced what it means to be and not be welcomed. He experienced what it was like not to have a place to lay his head and to be guest of sinners. He never wavered in his primary task of preaching the Kingdom of God. In fact, the criteria of our entrance into the Kingdom would be: "what we have done to the little ones." And the condemnation would be: "For I was hungry and you did not give me anything to eat: I was thirsty and you give nothing to drink; I was a stranger and you did not welcome me into your house; I was naked and you did not clothe me; I was sick and in prison and you did not visit me." (Mt.25:42-43).
  3. Pope John Paul II exhorts all of us: "in the Church no one is a stranger, and the Church is not foreign to anyone, anywhere. As a Sacrament of unity and thus a sign and a binding force for the whole human race, the Church is the place where immigrants are also recognised and accepted as brothers and sisters. It is the task of the various dioceses actively to ensure that these people, who are obliged to live outside the safety net of civil society, may find a sense of brotherhood in the Christian community." (Message for World and Migrants Day 1996)

1.4 The New Arrivals

The Jubilee, a time of pilgrimage and encounter

  1. A pilgrimage is a privileged occasion for meeting others.
  2. The believer’s personal journey in the footsteps of the Redeemer. (Incarnationis mysterium, n.7)
  3. “Like Abraham, to leave his kindred and father’s house - to open himself to those who are different.” (cf. Gn 12:1)

The Church, ‘sacrament of unity’

  1. “To gather into one the children of God who are scattered abroad” (Jn 11:52) and “unite them in the one human family in which God has made his dwelling.” (cf. Rv 21:3).
  2. “The challenge of our time is to assure a globalisation in solidarity, a globalisation without marginalisation.” (cf. n. 3).

‘Contemplating the mystery of the Incarnation’

  1. Works so that every person’s dignity is respected.
  2. He identified himself to a foreigner in need of shelter: “ I was a stranger and you welcomed me.” (Mt 25:35).
  3. “If anyone has the world’s goods and sees his brother in need, yet closes his heart against him, how does God’s love abide in him?” (1 Jn 3:17)

Furthering the unity of the human family

  1. The Church hears the suffering cry of all who are uprooted. The Church urges the State to recognise their right to emigration and encourages their integration….
  2. To work energetically to establish the universal brotherhood, true justice and a condition for lasting peace. (Paul VI, Encyclical Octogesima adveniens, n. 17)

2. CONCERN ON SOCIAL ISSUES

2.1 The Labour Situation

Role of the Church

  1. The right to speak out on social issues (Rerum Novarum)
  2. To examine “the signs of the times” in light of the Gospel (Gaudium et Spes)
  3. To spread in society Gospel values: reconciliation and unity (Rerum Novarum)
  4. Justice demands that the dignity of the human person be respected (Rerum Novarum)
  5. “Action on behalf of justice and participation in the transformation of the world fully appear to us as a constitutive dimension of the preaching of the Gospel, or in other words of the Church mission for the redemption of the human race and its liberation from every oppressive situation” (Justice in the World)

Role of workers & employers

  1. Human dignity must be upheld: Reasonable distribution of work allowing an employee to enjoy family life, faith, and community life. (Rerum Novarum)
  2. Just wages: sufficient to support a family, allowances to mothers at home. (Laborem Exercens) Workers’ savings must be respected (Rerum Novarum)
  3. It’s inhuman to use men and women for profit. No one is allowed to oppress the poor for his/her own profit. (Rerum Novarum)
  4. Employers and workers need each other. (Rerum Novarum)
  5. To uphold the role of workers’ unions and the natural right of men and women to join unions. (Rerum Novarum) Unions are a mouthpiece to voice workers’ rights, they bring about social order and worker solidarity. (Laborem Exercens)
  6. What promotes justice, brotherhood, more human societal order is more valuable than all technical progresses. (Gaudium et Spes)
  7. Craving for profit and thirst for power is rooted in personal sin. Development for a “more human life” calls for change in one’s behaviour and way of life. The option for the poor demands a consistent lifestyle. (Sollicitudo Rei Socialis)

Role of the State

  1. To serve the common good and to protect the right of the workers, each class of citizen, according to the principle of distributive justice. (Rerum Novarum) There is a need to move from economics to politics. The political power must be exercised for the common good. (Octogesima Adveniens)
  2. Wherever economic development is not guided by moral understanding and directed toward the common good, it becomes a source of oppression. (Sollicitudo Rei Socialis)
  3. Fundamentals: “Priority of labour over capital”, “primacy of people over things”. The human person is above things & capital and has to be given his rightful dignity and priority. (Laborem Exercens)
  4. Complete development requires developing a spirit of solidarity. (Populorum Progressio)
  5. The development of technology creates interdependence among people. However genuine dialogue is not taking place. (Gaudium et Spes)
  6. It is not just and human to organise the economic activity to the prejudice of the person. (Gaudium et Spes) More wealth produced has to result in its equitable distribution. (Populorum Progressio)
  7. Unemployment and under-employment are causes of humiliation and loss of self-respect: there is a need for a continual re-appraisal of human work. (Sollicitudo Rei Socialis)

2.2 Caring for the Environment

  1. “God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good.” (Gen. 1:31) For Francis, the universe reveals the footprints of its Creator. Every thing and everybody comes from the same goodness of the Creator, creation is a manifestation of God’s Being. (St. Bonaventure)
  2. “The creation was subjected to futility, not of its own will but by the will of him who subjected it in hope; because the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay and obtain the glorious liberty of the children of God.” (Rm. 8:19-21)
  3. "It is the duty of Christians and of all who look to God as the Creator to protect the environment by restoring a sense of reverence for the whole of God's creation. It is the Creator's will that man should treat nature not as a ruthless exploiter but an intelligent and responsible administrator. The Synod Fathers pleaded in a special way for greater responsibility on the part of the leaders of nations, legislators, business people and all who are directly involved in the management of the earth's resources. They underlined the need to educate people, especially the young, in environmental responsibility, training them in the stewardship over creation which God had entrusted to humanity. The protection of the environment is not only a technical question; it is also and above all an ethical issue. All have a moral duty to care for the environment, not only for their own good but also for the good of future generations." (Ecclesia in Asia, No. 41)

2.3 Life concerns

  1. "Jesus did not only treat and heal the sick, but he was also a tireless promoter of health through his saving presence, teaching and action. Called to continue Jesus' mission, the Church must seek to promote a full and ordered life for everyone. In the context of the promotion of good health and quality of life correctly understood, two duties deserve the Christian's special attention. First of all the defence of life. The second duty which Christians cannot shirk concerns the promotion of a health worthy of the human being." (Message for the World Day of the Sick for the year 2000 : Contemplate the face of Christ in the Sick, August 1999)
  2. "Whoever lives and believes in me shall never die." (Jn 11:26)
  3. "I came that they may have life, and have it abundantly." (Jn 10:10)
  4. "Every threat to human dignity and life must necessarily be felt in the Church's very heart (cf. Mk 16:15)
  5. "In the mystery of the Redemption man becomes newly "expressed" and, in a way, is newly created. (Redemptor Hominis, p. 35, No. 10)
  6. There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus. (Gal 3:28)
  7. God "gave his only Son" in order that man "should not perish but have eternal life". (cf. Jn 3:16)

2.4 Civic participation

  1. Democratic message in the Bible
  2. According to the Acts of the Apostles, after the death of Judas, Peter together with the brothers in the congregation elected Matthias to replace Judas as an apostle. (Acts 1:15-26) In another passage in Acts, it stated that the apostles and elders decided to choose delegates to send to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas. (Act 15:22-35) These two passages show the participatory process in choosing people.

  3. Participation by All in Public Life
  4. It is fully consonant with human nature that there should be politico-juridical structures providing all citizens without any distinction with ever improving and effective opportunities to play an active part in the establishment of the juridical foundations of the political community, in the administration of public affairs, in determining the aims and the terms of reference of public bodies, and in the election of political leaders. Every citizen ought to be mindful of his right and his duty to promote the common good by using his vote, (Gaudium et Spes, 75)

  5. The Political Community and the Church
  6. The Church, by reason of her role and competence, is not identified with any political community nor bound by ties to any political system. It is at once the sign and the safeguard of the transcendental dimension of the human person… But it never places its hopes in any privileges accorded to it by civil authority; indeed, it will give up the exercise of certain legitimate rights whenever it becomes clear that their use will compromise the sincerity of its witness , or whenever new circumstances call for a revised approach. But at all times and in all places the Church should have true freedom to preach the faith, to proclaim its teaching about society, to carry out its task among men without hindrance, and to pass moral judgements even in matters relating to politics, whenever the fundamental rights of man or the salvation of souls requires it. The means, the only means, it may use are those which are in accord with the Gospel and the welfare of all men according to the diversity of times and circumstances. (Gaudium et Spes, 76)

  7. Civic Participation

“The Church values the democratic system inasmuch as it ensures the participation of citizens in making political choices, guarantees to the governed the possibility both of electing and holding accountable those who govern the, and of replacing them through peaceful means when appropriate. Thus she cannot encourage the formation of narrow ruling groups which usurp the power of the State for individual interests or for ideological ends… Democracy is possible only in a State ruled by law, and on the basis of a correct conception of the human person. It requires that the necessary conditions be present for the advancement both of the individual through education and formation in true ideals, and of the “subjectivity” of society through the creation of structures of participation and shared responsibility.” (Centesimus Annus, 46)